Philly Leader

At the heart of education is a promise: the promise of opportunity, growth, and a brighter future.

Yet, for countless students in Pennsylvania's consistently lowest-performing schools, this promise remains elusive, trapped behind barriers of geographic limitations, economic restrictions, or limited access to quality instruction.

In many parts of the state, such as Philadelphia, students and parents desperately seek better educational opportunities. Parents with children in the bottom 15% performing public schools in Pennsylvania often face challenges that hinder the delivery of quality education. These challenges include overcrowded classrooms, increased violence, and a need for more educators.

The House Republican Policy Committee recently convened to discuss school choice with eager parents and educators advocating for change in what they describe as a broken and outdated education system.

The change they advocated for was the Pennsylvania Award for Student Success (PASS) scholarship program—a bipartisan policy initiative aimed at providing families with the opportunity to select an educational curriculum most suitable for their child's needs. Access to these scholarship dollars and more educational choices empowers parents as they take an active role in their child's education, fostering a sense of ownership and partnership between families and schools.

Introducing competition and encouraging innovation through PASS scholarships is seen by supporters as a catalyst for positive change. Students would have the freedom to leave underperforming schools instead of being confined to a one-size-fits-all government-run system. Both private and public schools would compete to attract students by improving curricula, engaging parents, creating modern learning environments, and prioritizing student well-being.

Opponents argue that PASS scholarships divert resources away from struggling schools. However, proponents counter that funding for PASS scholarships would come from a separate state account while preserving full funding for traditional K-12 public education.

During one Republican Policy Committee hearing, a mother from Philadelphia noted she is a Democrat but emphasized that this issue transcends party lines. She testified that if implemented, this program would force schools to “up their game…and hold their schools accountable.” By embracing competition in education, advocates believe it will create a system where schools are driven to excel—breaking the cycle of underperforming institutions—and where students gain access to diverse and innovative learning opportunities.

Pennsylvania has an opportunity to lead in educational innovation by adopting PASS scholarships as a transformative solution for those who need it most.

As the Pennsylvania House of Representatives returns to session with legislators filling the capitol building once again, there is an opportunity to pass this bipartisan school choice initiative which could have positive generational impacts. Democrat Governor Josh Shapiro promised support during his campaign; now is seen as the time to deliver on that promise for Pennsylvania's next generation.

___